23andMe VS The Genealogist

UPDATED Jun. 2018
Table Of Contents+

After making the initial decision to explore your ancestry and genetic origins, you are faced with a multitude of nuances, separating one ancestry DNA testing company from the next. The Genealogist and 23andMe are both excellent choices for the task at hand, but one will certainly come out on top once you identify your specific needs and expectations. Their services, although high-quality and professional, differ in small but important aspects, even though they seemingly do the same thing. Our comparison will help you spot those differences between The Genealogist and 23andMe, allowing you to make an optimal and fully personalized choice.

The Genealogist
Genealogy plus Family Tree DNA portfolio
VS
23andMe
Explore your ancestral origins

Highlights

The Genealogist
The Genealogist is a genealogy-centered website operated by Genealogy Supplies (Jersey) Limited and partnered with Family Tree DNA in order to complement its service with ancestry DNA testing.
  • Offers an extensive list of genealogical sources and data sets
  • Family Tree DNA testing portfolio, staff, and processing lab
  • Solid privacy & security policy and worldwide shipping
  • Price: $142.43
  • Shipping:
23andMe
Besides offering one of the most reliable ancestry DNA tests, 23andMe is also the only company to provide health results in your final report, indicating numerous health risks and genetic traits.
  • Health reports show potential for hereditary conditions
  • 570,000 genetic markers checked within Ancestry Service
  • Company Database contains around 2 million registered users
  • Price: $99.00
  • Shipping:Worldwide (Not Available In All Countries)

Compare Features

The Genealogist
Tests
Sample Collection Type
Genetic Markers Checked
Geographic Regions Covered
Ancestral Makeup Report
Paternal Lineage
Maternal Lineage
Neanderthal Percentage
Native American DNA Coverage
Jewish DNA Coverage
Cousin matching
Database Size
Family Tree Integration
Chromosome Browser
Health Report
Average Result Time
Research Participation
Raw Data Upload
Raw Data Download
Technology
Privacy and Security
23andMe
Tests
23andMe offers the following ancestry DNA testing solutions: - Ancestry Service - Health + Ancestry Service With Ancestry Service, you receive an overview of your ethnic percentages, ancestry timeline, haplogroups, and Neanderthal DNA percentage in your final report. If you opt for the second option, your final report will also include health-related results.
Sample Collection Type
Saliva
Genetic Markers Checked
570,000+
Geographic Regions Covered
150 Worldwide Regions
Ancestral Makeup Report
Paternal Lineage
Maternal Lineage
Neanderthal Percentage
Native American DNA Coverage
Jewish DNA Coverage
Cousin matching
Database Size
2,000,000
Family Tree Integration
Chromosome Browser
Health Report
Average Result Time
6-8 Weeks
Research Participation
Raw Data Upload
Raw Data Download
Technology
Illumina OmniExpress
Privacy and Security
23andMe stores your personal info separately from your genetic material for complete anonymity. The company will never share or sell your personal or genetic info without your explicit consent. It will use your data for research purposes, however, as aggregated data cannot be used to positively identify you as an individual. To keep your connection with its website safe, 23andMe uses SSL technology and follows the latest security standards in the industry.

Compare Ratings

The Genealogist
FINAL RATING
9.1/10
Scope Of DNA Test(s)
Test Processing Times
Privacy & Security
Value For Money
Overall Experience
23andMe
FINAL RATING
7.5/10
Scope Of DNA Test(s)
Test Processing Times
Privacy & Security
Value For Money
Overall Experience

Compare User Reviews

The Genealogist
  • Submitted By Alex Miller on 12/28/2017
    Tell me if I'm missing something here but isn't family tree dna cheaper like a lot??
  • Submitted By Indiana George on 11/18/2017
    I ordered from the Genealogist website, I get notification my fam. tree dna account is ready, my credit card says something else... What's going on here guys?!
  • Submitted By Jean Patrick on 10/12/2017
    Great service! Took a while to get the final results but that didn't diminish the overall experience for me.
  • Submitted By Vicky Strange on 10/02/2017
    Great stuff, but the report was too complicated for me at first.
23andMe
  • Submitted By Judah Davidson on 05/25/2018
    Being Ashkenazi Jewish and testing on 23andMe is basically useless. They categorize us as "100% European" and that sheds ZERO light on our actual ethnic breakdown. According to 23andMe, Ashkenazi Jews are "100% European" and on their ethnic breakdown, we have 0% of any European sub group, WTF🤦🏻‍............. Ashkenazi Jews on 23andMe are also "0% middle eastern." Did I mention their huge issue with "unassigned ancestry" and the nebulous "broadly" category? Save your money and wait until there are holiday sales, like DNA day and mothers day, and find a reputable company. 23andMe is garbage for ancestry testing, I can't address the health testing of their site...
  • Submitted By Dorothy Clark on 05/20/2018
    I purchased 23andme tests for my entire family after my grandfather died and I felt a sudden need to learn more about my family and ancestors. I found a ton of matches online, learned everything about my paternal line and even managed to get a family surname book for my grandfather. 23andme helped me solve a puzzle I though impossible and I would definitely recommed it to all people out there having questions about their ancestors and immediate family.
  • Submitted By Clara Jennings on 05/19/2018
    The only dna test that gave me health report on top of my ancestry! Very interesting results and def worth the price.
  • Submitted By Niki Chiaroscuro on 05/17/2018
    I would give this company ZERO stars if that were possible. It was a waste of $, X & saliva. A lot of inaccurate & vague percentages. No ethnicities found, just a lot of continents & percentages to countinents. SAVE YOUR MONEY!

Winner

The Genealogist is a website under the corporate umbrella of Genealogy Supplies (Jersey) Limited dedicated to genealogical research and complemented with ancestry DNA testing. The genetic piece of the puzzle is provided by none other than Family Tree DNA. Read more about this promising partnership in our in-depth review of The Genealogist and its services.

Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.