MyHeritage VS AncestryDNA

UPDATED Apr. 2019
Table Of Contents+
This website features affiliate links. For purchases made via these links, we earn commissions that allow us to keep producing helpful content. To find out more click here. Close

My Heritage and AncestryDNA are the two biggest rivals when it comes to ancestry DNA testing with genealogical complementation. Both companies offer state-of-the-art ancestry DNA tests designed to explore your ethnic percentages and tell you more about your direct paternal and maternal lines. They also feature extensive genealogical databases with billions of historical records in the form of old documents, personal journals, newspaper articles, and written stories.

Choosing between the two DNA testing providers can be pretty challenging, so we made this detailed My Heritage vs. AncestryDNA comparison. Once you have a parallel overview of all the most important features of these two DNA testing companies, you can easily make the right decision regarding your needs.

MyHeritage
Interdisciplinary ancestry exploration
VS
AncestryDNA
Find your complete ethnic origins

Highlights

MyHeritage
MyHeritage offers ancestry DNA testing complemented by billions of genealogical records, allowing its users to get a complete picture of their genetic heritage and get in touch with unknown relatives.
  • Top-of-the-line sample processing facility/accurate results
  • Numerous features and subscription plans available to users
  • 40 million family trees, 2.6 million profiles, 8 billion records
  • Price: $69.00
  • Shipping:Unknown
AncestryDNA
AncestryDNA is a genetic test developed by Ancestry, the largest genealogical enterprise in the world. The results are backed by various genealogical sources, forming a complete picture of your ancient/recent ancestry.
  • More than 700,000 DNA markers checked for optimal precision
  • Search for potential matches among 7 million DNA signatures
  • Download your raw DNA data file to use with other companies
  • Price: $99.00
  • Shipping:35 Countries

Compare Features

MyHeritage
Tests
MyHeritage offers one ancestry DNA test - MyHeritage DNA Test; The test explores your autosomal and gender genes for a full overview of your ethnic percentages. If you subscribe to the company's services, you can complement your final results with billions of genealogical records in its database.
Sample Collection Type
Cheek Swab
Genetic Markers Checked
690,000
Geographic Regions Covered
Unknown
Ancestral Makeup Report
Paternal Lineage
Maternal Lineage
Neanderthal Percentage
Native American DNA Coverage
Jewish DNA Coverage
Cousin matching
Database Size
New, Still Growing
Family Tree Integration
Chromosome Browser
Health Report
Average Result Time
3-4 Weeks
Research Participation
Raw Data Upload
Raw Data Download
Technology
Illumina
Privacy and Security
MyHeritage collects only the information necessary to provide its services, process payments, and give you the optimal ancestry DNA testing experience. You can delete or modify your personal info as many times as you choose and MyHeritage will never share, sell or lease it unless required to do so by law.
AncestryDNA
Tests
AncestryDNA offers one ancestry DNA test - Ancestry DNA Test. Your final report will provide you with a detailed breakdown of your ancestry. You can also complement your results with billions of genealogical records in the company's database.
Sample Collection Type
Saliva
Genetic Markers Checked
700,000+
Geographic Regions Covered
350 Worldwide Regions
Ancestral Makeup Report
Paternal Lineage
Maternal Lineage
Neanderthal Percentage
Native American DNA Coverage
Jewish DNA Coverage
Cousin matching
Database Size
7,000,000
Family Tree Integration
Chromosome Browser
Health Report
Average Result Time
6-8 Weeks
Research Participation
Raw Data Upload
Raw Data Download
Technology
Illumina OmniExpress
Privacy and Security
With AncestryDNA, you are 100% in charge of your DNA testing kit, your samples, and your personal data from the moment you place your order until you receive your final results. You control who can access your data and the company will never try to interfere with your administration or sell your sensitive info to third parties. You can also transfer your administrator rights to another person if you so choose.

Compare Ratings

MyHeritage
FINAL RATING
9.9/10
Scope Of DNA Test(s)
Test Processing Times
Privacy & Security
Value For Money
Overall Experience
AncestryDNA
FINAL RATING
9.8/10
Scope Of DNA Test(s)
Test Processing Times
Privacy & Security
Value For Money
Overall Experience

Compare User Reviews

MyHeritage
  • Submitted By N on 04/06/2019
    Just an absolutely horrible experience. This site obviously has a bias set to its ratings. The math does not work with these ratings.
  • Submitted By Kathy on 01/20/2019
    Don't waste your money on MyHeritage getting your DNA tested. I have traced my family tree back on both sides of my family pretty far. I have actual proof of being Cherokee since my mother's paternal grandfather was full-blood, her maternal grandmother was full-blood and there is also Cherokee on my father's side. My 5th gr Grandmother is listed in the Cherokee By Blood, Her granddaughter put in an application for the Eastern Cherokee tribe and they are listed on the Guion Miller Roll. Can't get much more Cherokee than that. My DNA results came back that I am zero % American Indian. Also said I am zero % Scottish or Irish yet I have my family traced back to the year 1068 and we are related to Sir William Wallace. When I called to complain and say I wanted a refund I was told that their DNA tests are quite accurate. I told the guy apparently they are not accurate or they would have gotten my DNA correctly. His excuse about not finding the Scottish or Irish was that more than likely my family originated in England and migrated to Scotland and Ireland. Uh... NO! I asked if he was going to change the history books and also let Mel Gibson know that he based his movie in the wrong country? As for the reason they didn't find any American Indian in my DNA he said that many Indians don't trust the white man and so they don't want to provide DNA samples to compare to. Ok, so how are other companies able to test for American Indian DNA. He then said there are over 500 tribes they don't have samples for. I told him that even if that were true, the Cherokee are one of the largest tribes in the U.S. They were one of the 5 civilized tribes. I told him that in case he didn't know what that meant, it meant that they were one of the tribes to adopt the customs of the white settlers and generally had good relations with them. They were one of the only tribes to have a written syllabary making it possible for them to read and write in their language. There are 3 federally recognized Cherokee tribes as well as some not federally recognized. So, how is it that they do not have ANY DNA from this tribe? He just continued to repeat to me that there are over 500 tribes that they do not DNA from to be able to compare to. I then asked him this - When MyHeritage very first started, how did they test their very first customer? Because if I was understanding him correctly, they needed something to compare to and if it was the very first customer then what did they compare to? I told him I felt their company is falsely advertising and that I wanted a refund. You can't advertise and charge people money for doing something if you aren't going to or aren't able to do it correctly. They are not able to test people's DNA correctly if they can not test for everything. He kept telling me how accurate their tests are but they are not accurate and I was very disappointed with the results. I will be posting this review on Yelp.com as well as Angie's List and any other review site that I am able to post on. I still want a refund and plan to call them again as well as write to them. It's unethical to charge that much money for something and not do it correctly. I want my money back so I can find someone who actually knows what they are doing and can test my DNA correctly. Don't waste your money on this,
  • Submitted By Samantha R Boykin on 12/26/2018
    I ordered the DNA kite for my husband for Christmas its been six weeks still not here, and cant get anyone on on the phone. I dont get all the great reviews im very dissapointed .
  • Submitted By MCD on 06/20/2018
    My Heritage offer a fantastic online facility to research your family history. I feel connected to people whose blood and DNA I carry but died hundred of years ago. I had no idea, until a few days ago my Mothers side of the family were Millers and Corn Dealers based in a sleepy village in Suffolk, England. There also appears to be a child one of my Great Grandmothers had that nobody knew anything about..... such a tantalising mystery!!
AncestryDNA
  • Submitted By STEVEN WOOTEN on 04/13/2019
    AncestryDNA is a complete rip off. Everything they told us, we knew from googling our last name (which I had done). They did not include anything outside of that information. They did not include anything from my Native American ancestry at all. A person can look at me and tell it's there. I certainly do not look like I am completely Irish and British considering my dark skin, hair, and eyes. What a total waste of time and money. I do not recommend ever using them. There has to be more reputable companies out there.
  • Submitted By Sofia on 19/02/2019
    I have been really disappointed with my results!!!! I am 100% sure I am half Russian and half Italian but the results showed that I am 0% Russian an 27% Italian. Even my Native American results (which were 1%) were higher than Russian! I can not believe it, because my mums side is fully Russian. I hope the company will improve in the future.
  • Submitted By Abigail Hunt on 10/15/2018
    After testing with Family Tree DNA, my husband and I decided to expand our list of relatives and explore the database offered by Ancestry. We found so many new relatives, some of which were located in Europe, out of all places. If you’re adamant about researching your genetic past in-depth, doing a single test is not enough, not by a long shot. Ancestry gave us much more information than FTDNA, but we still have to do the 23andMe test and check their database as well.
  • Submitted By Roy Fisher on 09/13/2018
    Ancestry definitely has the best geographical coverage and can tell you the most about your ancient relatives and overall genetic background. On top of that, it’s also great for family genealogists like myself since it gave me access to soooo many old documents I almost started crying when I thought of the time wasted elsewhere.

Winner

MyHeritage is a DNA testing provider founded in 2003 in Israel. It combines genetic research with genealogy, allowing its users to create family profiles, print family trees, share photos, perform DNA testing, stay in touch with relatives, research family history, and much more. Read all about its services in our MyHeritage review.

Scope Of DNA Tests

MyHeritage provides a direct-to-customer ancestry DNA test with an at-home testing kit based on cheek swabs. The processing part of the test examines 690,000 genetic markers across your autosomal chromosome pairs. This means that MyHeritage doesn’t check your gender chromosomes and can’t provide you with stand-alone results regarding your direct paternal or maternal lineages. The company also offers more than 8.96 billion historical records and over 40 million family trees. The regions covered by the test and the size of the database are currently unknown.

AncestryDNA, on the other hand, opted for a saliva-based at-home testing kit. The test checks 700,000+ genetic markers and explores all 23 pairs of your chromosomes. Your final report will include ethnic estimate based on 350 worldwide regions and you’ll be able to search for genetic matches across 7 million + profiles in the company’s database.

Test Processing Times

MyHeritage’s final report is usually generated within 3-4 weeks.  

AncestryDNA test results will arrive 6-8 weeks after your DNA sample reaches its processing facility.  

Privacy & Security

MyHeritage will never disclose your personal information except in some cases determined by law. The company will collect your identification and family info, your DNA samples and results, and your usage of the website. 

AncestryDNA has a very strict privacy policy and declares you the administrator of your personal test and profile. You’ll be able to customize the public visibility of your test and even transfer your administrator rights if you so choose. The point is, no one will be able to see or access your personal info without your explicit permission.  

Value For Money

The price of MyHeritage ancestry test is 99$, but you can also get a free report by transferring your raw DNA data from other companies, which is a great financial benefit. You can start off with a free plan and work your way toward the Premium (9.17$ per month) and Premium Plus (10.95$ per month) subscriptions. Access to the genealogical database is charged 13.27$ per month. In other words, MyHeritage offers excellent value for the money invested. 

AncestryDNA doesn’t feature subscription plans and all you’ll ever have to pay is 99$ for the main test. However, its father company Ancestry.com LLC is the biggest genealogical database on the planet, featuring numerous brands you can use to uncover all the secrets of your past. To put it simply, Ancestry offers the most detailed ancestral reports and information for the price.  

Overall Experience

MyHeritage was envisioned as a genealogical database, but it outgrew its original frame and implemented a genetic component into its business model. Its genetic processing rivals and even surpasses most of the competitors in terms of speed, accuracy, and scope.

AncestryDNA needs no special introductions. It is an integral part of the world’s largest genealogical conglomerate and features high-quality ancestry DNA testing. Keeping in mind its popularity, you can see just how far MyHeritage has progressed over the last couple of years when it can stand on equal ground with giants like AncestryDNA.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.