AncestryDNA VS 23andMe

UPDATED Dec. 2018
Table Of Contents+

If you want to test your DNA and reveal your ancestry and ethnicity with great precision, AncestryDNA and 23andMe should be on top of your list. Both companies offer cutting-edge ancestry DNA tests, but they also add certain features that make their services unique.

AncestryDNA pertains to the largest genealogical conglomerate on the planet, which means you'll also be able to explore billions of genealogical sources and complement the results of your genetic testing with genealogical data. 23andMe, on the other hand, is one of the few companies that offer health-related results with ancestry examination.

Our detailed 23andMe vs. AncestryDNA comparison is designed to list all the important features of both companies, pointing out their advantages and potential shortcomings.

AncestryDNA
Find your complete ethnic origins
VS
23andMe
Explore your ancestral origins

Highlights

AncestryDNA
AncestryDNA is a genetic test developed by Ancestry, the largest genealogical enterprise in the world. The results are backed by various genealogical sources, forming a complete picture of your ancient/recent ancestry.
  • More than 700,000 DNA markers checked for optimal precision
  • Search for potential matches among 7 million DNA signatures
  • Download your raw DNA data file to use with other companies
  • Price: $99.00
  • Shipping:35 Countries
23andMe
Besides offering one of the most reliable ancestry DNA tests, 23andMe is also the only company to provide health results in your final report, indicating numerous health risks and genetic traits.
  • Health reports show potential for hereditary conditions
  • 570,000 genetic markers checked within Ancestry Service
  • Company Database contains around 2 million registered users
  • Price: $99.00
  • Shipping:Worldwide (Not Available In All Countries)

Compare Features

AncestryDNA
Tests
AncestryDNA offers one ancestry DNA test - Ancestry DNA Test. Your final report will provide you with a detailed breakdown of your ancestry. You can also complement your results with billions of genealogical records in the company's database.
Sample Collection Type
Saliva
Genetic Markers Checked
700,000+
Geographic Regions Covered
350 Worldwide Regions
Ancestral Makeup Report
Paternal Lineage
Maternal Lineage
Neanderthal Percentage
Native American DNA Coverage
Jewish DNA Coverage
Cousin matching
Database Size
7,000,000
Family Tree Integration
Chromosome Browser
Health Report
Average Result Time
6-8 Weeks
Research Participation
Raw Data Upload
Raw Data Download
Technology
Illumina OmniExpress
Privacy and Security
With AncestryDNA, you are 100% in charge of your DNA testing kit, your samples, and your personal data from the moment you place your order until you receive your final results. You control who can access your data and the company will never try to interfere with your administration or sell your sensitive info to third parties. You can also transfer your administrator rights to another person if you so choose.
23andMe
Tests
23andMe offers the following ancestry DNA testing solutions: - Ancestry Service - Health + Ancestry Service With Ancestry Service, you receive an overview of your ethnic percentages, ancestry timeline, haplogroups, and Neanderthal DNA percentage in your final report. If you opt for the second option, your final report will also include health-related results.
Sample Collection Type
Saliva
Genetic Markers Checked
570,000+
Geographic Regions Covered
150 Worldwide Regions
Ancestral Makeup Report
Paternal Lineage
Maternal Lineage
Neanderthal Percentage
Native American DNA Coverage
Jewish DNA Coverage
Cousin matching
Database Size
2,000,000
Family Tree Integration
Chromosome Browser
Health Report
Average Result Time
6-8 Weeks
Research Participation
Raw Data Upload
Raw Data Download
Technology
Illumina OmniExpress
Privacy and Security
23andMe stores your personal info separately from your genetic material for complete anonymity. The company will never share or sell your personal or genetic info without your explicit consent. It will use your data for research purposes, however, as aggregated data cannot be used to positively identify you as an individual. To keep your connection with its website safe, 23andMe uses SSL technology and follows the latest security standards in the industry.

Compare Ratings

AncestryDNA
FINAL RATING
9.8/10
Scope Of DNA Test(s)
Test Processing Times
Privacy & Security
Value For Money
Overall Experience
23andMe
FINAL RATING
9.7/10
Scope Of DNA Test(s)
Test Processing Times
Privacy & Security
Value For Money
Overall Experience

Compare User Reviews

AncestryDNA
  • Submitted By Abigail Hunt on 10/15/2018
    After testing with Family Tree DNA, my husband and I decided to expand our list of relatives and explore the database offered by Ancestry. We found so many new relatives, some of which were located in Europe, out of all places. If you’re adamant about researching your genetic past in-depth, doing a single test is not enough, not by a long shot. Ancestry gave us much more information than FTDNA, but we still have to do the 23andMe test and check their database as well.
  • Submitted By Roy Fisher on 09/13/2018
    Ancestry definitely has the best geographical coverage and can tell you the most about your ancient relatives and overall genetic background. On top of that, it’s also great for family genealogists like myself since it gave me access to soooo many old documents I almost started crying when I thought of the time wasted elsewhere.
  • Submitted By Roger Wallen on 08/03/2018
    Report did not show any native American ancestry and I know it is strong Cherokee. Even some of my Father's cousins have names like White Bird, Red Bud and James Crow. I called the company and was told that it is almost impossible to show native American ancestry, yet they show a commercial where a woman it surprised that she is 27% native American. VERY misleading. They did not even suggest a second test. Probably would be a lot different.
  • Submitted By Eve Rogerson on 06/06/2018
    I think a lot of people turn to AncestryDNA expecting some magical DNA analysis only to end up with more questions. After centuries of marriages/couplings there is no way you can find exactly where your DNA traces back to. For example, with the European DNA, we simply saw western European but there are so many countries there and the people that lived in those countries moved and migrated and mixed with others, that mixed with even more. It would be impossible to directly trace that. Also, If you know anything at all about DNA, you would know that you get a random 50% from each parent...each child will carry a different trait or amount of a trait per parent. For me trying to trace the DNA of my father and I, gave me a few surprising details but our full ethnicity but his was vastly different from my own. After he was matched as my father and he found an older half brother, we opted out of further matching. Having that option gives me something to look forward to in the future but not right now...I don't like surprises and definitely couldn't handle any new additions to our small family.
23andMe
  • Submitted By Anna Bennett on 09/02/2018
    My daughter bought me this test and I was amazed (to say the least) to learn of my origins! It looks like I'm mostly from Europe. Fascinating!
  • Submitted By Havier Torres on 08/27/2018
    23 and me is the best DNA testing company there is. I love researching my ancestry and did a couple of tests with other famous companies - my experience with 23 and me has been the best so far. Apart from learning a lot about my heritage, I also received a health report - this is something only 23 and me provides. The test gives great value for the money spent and I plan on buying it as a Christmas gift to my family.
  • Submitted By D. Collins on 08/19/2018
    This has been an amazing experience. I learned so much and had a lot of fun along the way. Thank you!
  • Submitted By Sharon on 08/16/2018
    I selected 23 and me for DNA testing because two friends had used this company, and they recommended it. Even though the quoted time is approximately 6-8 weeks, theirs was completed in approximately 4 weeks. My experience has been less satisfactory. My sample was mailed in June, and notification was received 2 days later stating the sample had been received and testing was underway. For 5 weeks, my status remained at the point where they were reading the chip. Although this seemed like an unrealistic time, I assumed they simply were not updating my account the first few weeks. After 5 weeks at the same stage, I surmised that the company was either a scam or they have inept employees. I had entered our contract in good will and completed a gamut of questions so my results could be used to further research. As a research scientist, the company had lost all credibility and I would never trust them to participate in ethical research. I changed my status, disallowing the company to use my DNA results for any type of research. Then I received an e-mail stating that my results would be delayed a few more weeks because of a computer upgrade. In the meantime, I began reading reviews. Some customers who submitted their DNA after mine was submitted had already received their results. Others had received a message regarding the additional delay due to computer delay. It's been almost 2 months since the notification that they received my sample. There has been no change in the status of my sample. I have wasted $200. Since the company has not lived up to the advertisement, and have proven to be untrustworthy, any results they provide in the future will be suspect. My intent had been to give these kits to friends and family at Christmas. Now that it has become evident that 23 and me is not a reputable company, I will research other companies who provide this service.

Winner

AncestryDNA offers one of the best and most precise ancestry DNA tests on the market, paired with an active online community and billions of historical records to complement your exploration. Learn more about its complete offer in our objective AncestryDNA review.

Scope Of DNA Tests

23andMe offers ancestry DNA testing + health-related results. The basic ancestry service checks 570,000 genetic markers and covers 31 genetic populations across 150+ regions around the world. The final report will also include your potential Jewish, Native American, and Neanderthal percentages. The company database currently holds more than 2 million genetic profiles, but it doesn’t feature family tree integration. The health portion, which is optional, includes results concerning 43 carrier reports, 8 wellness factors, 8 health risks, and 22 trait reports. 

AncestryDNA test examines 700,000 genetic markers and covers 350 geographical regions. The results also include your potential Jewish and Native American percentages but not your Neanderthal genetic “leftovers.” AncestryDNA also allows you to generate your personal family tree and connect with potential relatives across 7 million profiles in its database. AncestryDNA doesn’t feature health results, but its parent company offers a database with more than 16 billion genealogical sources.     

Test Processing Times

Both companies take between 6 and 8 weeks to generate the final report.  

Privacy & Security

23andMe offers anonymous testing and its website is encrypted with SSL technology. Additionally, the company will not share your sensitive information with third parties without your explicit consent.  

AncestryDNA features a strict privacy policy, which puts you in charge of your account and personal information. You can customize the information visible to the public or transfer your administrator privileges any time. Bottom line, no one will be able to access your personal information without your permission.  

Value For Money

23andMe’s pricing policy is rather simple. Its ancestry service costs 99$ and you’ll have to pay 100$ extra if you want to receive your health report as well. In our opinion, this service is definitely worth the money if you’re interested in your genetic roots and DNA health risks.  

AncestryDNA also charges 99$ for its ancestral exploration. The company doesn’t provide any health-related testing, but you can use additional services offered by its parent company, Ancestry.com LLC. If you’re more interested in genealogical research than health risks, AncestryDNA is a clear-cut choice here.    

Overall Experience

23andMe is probably the most popular service of its kind and it pioneered the direct-to-customer model employed by all other similar companies today. The overall experience is smooth from the moment you place your order to the time you receive your final report. 23andMe is a serious company and it leaves zero room for errors.  

AncestryDNA belongs to the largest genealogical conglomerate in the world. As such, it has a reputation to uphold, so every service is as seamless as you can possibly imagine. Apart from genetic ancestry, you’ll also be able to delve deeper into your past with numerous brands and services offered by Ancestry.com LLC.

* All the prices on this website are subject to change without notice. While we put a great deal of effort into making sure that all the prices are accurate, one or more products may have outdated prices. Please visit the specific product’s official website for exact prices.
Join our mailing list to receive exclusive updates, giveaways and coupon codes directly to your inbox.